Sam BataynehMortgage · NMLS 332474
Buying a home · Guide

The home appraisal: what it checks and what to do if it comes in low.

The appraisal is the lender's independent opinion of what the home is worth, and the loan is sized from it. It is not an inspection and it is not the price. Here is what it does, what you are entitled to see, and the options when the value and the contract price do not match.

Illustration of homes on a palm-lined street in the Los Angeles area
Los Angeles · illustration
The appraisal

What does a mortgage appraisal do?

It gives the lender a licensed appraiser's opinion of the home's market value, so the lender knows the loan is backed by enough value. The lender orders it, and you usually pay for it.

The appraiser compares the home with recent sales of similar properties nearby, adjusts for differences such as size, lot, condition and features, and reaches an opinion of value as of a specific date. The lender then works from the lower of that value and the contract price when it sizes the loan.

An appraisal is not a home inspection. The CFPB says the two are different and that you generally need both: the appraisal is the lender's check on value, while the inspection you order checks the condition of the roof, the systems and the structure. A clean appraisal says nothing about a leaking water heater.

The appraisal

Do I get a copy of the appraisal?

Yes. For a first mortgage on a home, the lender must give you a free copy promptly after it is completed, and no later than three business days before closing.

Federal Regulation B requires the copy promptly upon completion, or three business days before closing, whichever comes first. You may waive the timing and agree to receive it at or before closing, but the waiver has to be given at least three business days before closing, except where the only change to an appraisal you already have is clerical.

Read it when it arrives, not at the closing table. Check the address, the square footage, the bedroom and bathroom count, and the comparable sales. Errors in basic facts are the easiest thing to correct.

The appraisal

What can I do if the appraisal comes in below the price?

You can bring more cash, renegotiate the price with the seller, challenge the value through a reconsideration request, or, if the appraisal contingency is still in place, cancel and recover the deposit.

A low appraisal changes the arithmetic of the loan, not the price in the contract. The lender lends from the appraised value, so either the price moves, the down payment grows, or the deal changes. Which option is realistic depends on how competitive the market for that home was and whether the appraisal contingency, with the deadline the purchase agreement sets, is still open.

In a fast California market, sellers sometimes ask buyers to agree in advance to cover a gap between the appraisal and the price. That is a contract term with real money behind it; work out how much cash it would take before agreeing to it.

The appraisal

How do I ask for a reconsideration of value?

Through the lender, before closing. For loans sold to Fannie Mae, the lender must have a written process, must tell you about it when it gives you the appraisal, and allows one borrower-requested reconsideration per appraisal.

Fannie Mae's Selling Guide sets out what the request must include: the borrower's name, the property address, the effective date of the appraisal, the appraiser's name and the date of the request; the specific parts of the report you believe are unsupported, inaccurate or deficient; up to five alternative comparable sales with their data sources, such as MLS numbers; and an explanation of why the new data supports a different value.

The lender reviews the request first, sends it to the appraiser through a standard process, and remains responsible for making sure the final value is supported. The request has to be submitted before closing. A good request is specific: a sale two streets away, of a similar size, closed in the last few months, that the appraiser did not use, is stronger than a general complaint that the number is low.

A reconsideration can also be used if you believe the appraisal reflects discrimination. In California, Business and Professions Code section 11424 bars licensed appraisers from basing an opinion of value on any characteristic protected by fair housing law, whether of the owners or occupants of the home or of the properties around it.

The appraisal

How long is an appraisal good for?

For loans sold to Fannie Mae, the appraisal must be dated within 12 months of closing, and if it is more than four months old, the appraiser must update it.

An update means the appraiser looks at the exterior again and reviews current market data to see whether the value has fallen since the original report. This matters on long escrows, new construction, and purchases where the search and the closing stretch over several months. Jumbo lenders set their own rules and can be stricter.

The appraisal

Can a loan close without a full appraisal?

Sometimes. Fannie Mae's automated system can offer “value acceptance” on some loans instead of an appraisal, generally where it has a prior appraisal of the same property on file.

Fannie Mae's guide lists the kinds of loans that can be considered: one-unit homes including condos, main homes and second homes, certain purchases and refinances, and investment property refinances. It excludes, among others, two- to four-unit homes and any transaction where the price or estimated value is $1,000,000 or more, which leaves out many California purchases. If the earlier appraisal was flagged for overvaluation, value acceptance is not offered. Many California purchases still need an appraisal, and jumbo loans usually do, sometimes two.

A worked example

How does the loan size work on one purchase?

A buyer agrees to pay $1,500,000 with $300,000 down, so the planned loan is $1,200,000, four-fifths of the price. The appraisal comes in at $1,450,000. Four-fifths of the appraised value is $1,160,000, so to keep the same loan-to-value the buyer needs $40,000 more cash, a lower price from the seller, a successful reconsideration of value, or another loan structure.

Loan size only: no rate or payment is shown here. Every loan is subject to credit and underwriting approval.

Common questions

More plain answers: the appraisal.

Who chooses the appraiser?
The lender, usually through an appraisal management company, under appraiser independence rules. Buyers, sellers and agents may not pick the appraiser or press for a number.
Is the appraisal the same as the county's assessed value?
No. The county assessor values the home separately, for property tax. After a purchase, the assessor reappraises the home as of the change in ownership, which usually leads to a supplemental tax bill, explained in the closing guide.
What if the appraisal comes in above the price?
The loan is still based on the lower figure, the contract price. A higher appraisal does not let you borrow more on a purchase, though it can be welcome news about the home's value.
Does a condo appraisal differ from a house appraisal?
The approach is similar, but the appraiser also looks at the project, and the lender separately reviews the homeowners association. The condo loans page explains the project review.

General education only. Each lender sets its own rules, and they change. Nothing here is a promise that a loan will be approved or of any terms. This is not tax, legal or investment advice: for those questions, ask your own CPA, attorney or business manager.

Questions about this?

Tell Sam what you are trying to do. Sam will walk through it with your own numbers.

Get started with Sam
Call Sam